When One Partner Wants to Stop Swinging


Answers
& Advice


2/27/2002

Hi,
     I surfed on your site and checked it out. It's very good.
     My wife and I were involved in swinging for about 5 yrs. We're in our early 40's now. We swung more as a hobby than a lifestyle. We first met other couples through the contact magazines by mail correspondence then went on-line. We never went to clubs or on a vacation to a swingers resort but may have wanted to check it out one day. We mostly partied with other couples one on one at their place or ours when we could get the kids on an overnight. Maybe every 2-3 months we'd party with another couple. We had a small circle of couples we'd take turns getting together with. We even got together just socially at times because we wanted to be friendly in and out of the bedroom with other couples. Some couples we drifted apart from, but a small core we remained with.
     My wife began to lose enthusiasm and then just wanted to stop swinging about 2 yrs. ago. I didn't want to stop but I gave it a try. She didn't have a problem getting together with couples socially and I thought I wouldn't but it bothers me more than her! I hoped she'd eventually come around again and we've had our discussions and arguments over it. It's been over 2 yrs. now and we're still stuck at an impasse.
     I think she's more afraid of me having too good a time with the other woman and that I'm looking for a substitute for her and that prevented her from having a good time with her swing partner after a while. I always told her and it's true, that I love to hear or see her having a good time with another man. Certainly I like to enjoy another woman but I tell her it's just recreational sex when we party with other couples. I always liked for her to tell me what she did when we partied separately with other couples and told her it turned me on, but I could see she wasn't very interested when I told her what I did with the other woman in the next room.
     Can you offer any advice or suggestions? I've told her I love her and am not going to leave her over swinging but I haven't been the same happy camper since we stopped.

Thanks.
TR

Dear TR,

     We sympathize with your difficulty in trying to return to a nonphysical relationship with previous swing partners. When someone changes the rules, the relationships change too. You can't go back to the way you were, because everyone is different now. We do not mean to imply, however, that couples who have partied together are obligated to do so every time they meet. We see several couples socially that we haven't swung with in years. But we don't feel restricted by that … we know we can if the mood strikes us.
     You say that your wife lost her enthusiasm about 2 years ago; but how enthusiastic was she prior to that? if she was an avid player and suddenly changed, then you must find out why. Speculation on our part would be worse than useless. On the other hand, if she never really liked swinging, and only went along because she was trying to please you, then you probably should abandon the idea if you want to remain married to her. Or, maybe, just maybe, a different approach to swinging would change her mind.
     We infer from your letter that your prior swinging experience was mostly closed, that is, you and your wife went your separate ways at parties. Although we have nothing against this practice per se, we have observed that swinging rarely improves the marriages of couples who resist sharing the sex-play experience.
     You will find our remaining advice in our books, Considering Swinging and Together Sex. If you and your wife read them both, you may find common ground to begin swinging again.
     But whatever the result, please remember that swinging is not critical to a successful and happy marriage … open and honest communication is.

Stay Playful,
Ed and Dana